Saturday, April 30, 2016

Round 2 Day 3

A cop was hard at work, poking around places they maybe weren't meant to be poking around.

"Dum de dum de dum. Oh! What's this?" The cop shone their flashlight on a small metallic object on the ground. "Huh. It looks kinda like a gun."

They picked it up, and immediately someone jumped out from behind a building. 

"Ah!" The cop shot out of instinct, only to realize that the gun was in fact a paintball gun. Pretty useless against a Mafia member in protective gear.

The next morning, the body of Lua, Cop was found in a shady part of town. The gun clutched in her hand made it look like she'd shot herself, but the angle was wrong, and upon further inspection, so was the gun.

It is now Day 2

Comment moderation will be turned off as soon as I've emailed out the results of everyone's night actions. You'll all receive an email, even if you decided to do nothing or did not submit an action. 

You can use this time to discuss amongst yourselves in the comment section and try to sleuth out the mafioso. You do not have to share the results of your investigations, though failing to do so may make you seem suspicious.

If you want to hang a suspected mafioso, you can type castvote [player's name]
If you type "vote" rather than "castvote," your vote will be valid if I see it. However, I'm gonna Ctrl-F "castvote" when tallying up, so that's not a guarantee. Also please avoid using the word castvote when you're not voting. Use vote instead, e.g. "I think I'm gonna vote for Fabi." and then later "castvoteFabi"
If you want to redact a vote (which you can only do before it's reached a majority), type unvote. Please use bold! The code for that is <b>[Bold text]</b>

You are not obligated to hang somebody, though failing to do so may give the mafioso an advantage. 

The day will end Monday May 2nd, at 9AM Pacific Time (5PM UK time) unless a majority is reached and a suspect is selected, or unless people vote skip day, which also requires a majority vote.

If a suspect is selected, their 24-hour defense phase will begin immediately, even if I am not online to say so. During that time, you may castvote "innocent" or "guilty," and you may change your vote at any time. The vote will not lock until the end of the defense phase.

SPECIAL ANNOUNCEMENT: Snow is out of town, so Lua can remain in the game for this day phase to fill Snow's spot. She does not have her own results because she's dead. I'll send her Snow's though.

The majority of votes needed today is 5.

If you have any questions, comment them in italics or email me.

Round 2 Players
1) Gemma
2) Dugglyn
3) Star
4) Lavender

5) Silente (Jai)
7) Vellichor (Elleni)
8) Keiron
9) Snow *Lua's filling in today if she wants to

Roles

Mafioso
Mafioso

Cop
Cop

Cop
Doctor
Coroner

Survivor

Player order and role order not related. Role assignments generated randomly.

140 comments:

Dugglyn Carzainia said...

LUA D:

Dugglyn Carzainia said...

I got Unsuspicious for Gemma.

Ace Pennman said...

I got unsuspicious for El

also, I'm back

Dugglyn Carzainia said...

Snow! :D

Hmm, okay. I'm kinda wondering why someone would kill Lua.
Who did she investigate?

Dugglyn Carzainia said...

Found it.

She investigated Lav and got suspicious.

Clue?

Ace Pennman said...

possibly. or someone is trying to set lav up?

Dugglyn Carzainia said...

That is also extremely likely.

Lavender Hope said...

I'VE BEEN FRAMED. D:

But if Lua was a cop, then that means there's only three left! Which means there will be more people lying than being truthful, /plus/ didn't Henry give someone /two/ badges during the night phase?? Meaning even a /cop/ could be lying!

Also, I investigated Star and got suspicious... This could still mean I'm either paranoid, insane, normal or lying...(adding that last one in there since it /is/ still an option, and I accept the risk of it being a possibility)

However, I'm starting to think I'm not the normal cop.

Hmm... what would be someone's reason for blaming me? Besides thinking I'm a threat. Wait no, that could be a really good reason. Never mind.

Dugglyn Carzainia said...

So what if it had something to do with who you investigated?

Or Lua's death could just be fairly random.

Star Inkbright said...

Right, so Lua was DEFINITELY a cop. I think.

Also, Lav got suspicious twice so she's either paranoid, insane or lying. (OR identified both the Mafia members. I know I'm not a Mafia member, but you guys don't.)

The fact that Lua died as a cop leaves us with either Gemma or Lav being a liar.

Dugglyn and Snow got unsuspicious again. They're both either regular, normal or lying.

And I got unsuspicious for Keiron, adding me to the regular/normal/lying category.

Star Inkbright said...

Regular/normal?
*facepalm*

^regular/naive

Star Inkbright said...

I think Lua's death may have been fairly random. I can't really see a strong motive.

Star Inkbright said...

^OR Dugglyn/Snow identified both Mafia members and are insane
Ugh so much thinking to do

Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...

I investigated Lua and got unsuspicious, so I'm not insane. That leaves me with doctor, coroner, survivor, normal and naive.

Star Inkbright said...

We already have too many unsuspicious people haha.

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

I got suspicious for Lua so i'm thinking i'm paranoid.

Star Inkbright said...

@Gemma: *nods*
If you're not lying, then Lav is lying, so if she's the Mafia and you got suspicious fir her and Lua, you'Re paranoid. However, she could be the doctor/coroner survivor, meaning her and Lua are both unsuspicious, meaning you could still be insane.
*puzzles over results*

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

I could be insane too.

So far, Lav is paranoid or insane, She's not regular as she got suspicious for me and star and i know i'm not a killer.
i'm paranoid or insane. I investigated Lav and Lua and got suspicious, lua is dead so she wasn't a killer but lav could still be.
Duggy is Naive or Regular. She got unsuspicious for star and I so i know she's not insane for me, but star could be a killer.
Elleni is either naive or regular, she got unsuspicious for lua and she obviously wasn't the killer so elleni isn't insane.
Keiron could still be all 3 as he hasn't commented yet.
Sil, as she says, is Naive or Reguler as she investigated lav and lua and lua isn't the killer so she's not insane.
Lua was a cop
star is naive or regular as she investigate keiron and snow and got unsuspicious i mean i guess technically she could still be insane as keiron and snow could be the killers together but i doubt keiron is. Again i might just be really niave cause i don't think he's lying to me.
Fnally, snow is Naive insane or regular still. She investigated sil and elleni and got unsuspicious for both so sil and elleni could be killing together.

Star Inkbright said...

So
If Lav Mafioso -
- Gemma paranoid
- Lua regular
- Someone else insane

If Lav doctor/coronor/survivor
- Gemma paranoid/insane
- Lua paranoid/insane

If Lav cop
- Gemma lying
- Lua paranoid
- Someone else insane

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

Now try to do that for the list of liars picking Naive, Star xD

Star Inkbright said...

*nods at Gemma* yep.

*really hopes someone else who hasn't commented yet gets a suspicious result bevause that would help cleat things up XD*

Star Inkbright said...

@Gemma: I would, but it would take hoursssssss XD XD Like 50% of us are lying!!
*has basically given up all hope on working out which of us is lying*

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

It would be easy to set lav up as 4 people investigated her so far.

Star Inkbright said...

*nods*

Ace Pennman said...

okay, so I'm making lists and I can't find it so I'll ask

has anyone else investigated El?

Star Inkbright said...

It must be so much easier for the Mafia members . . . They only have to identify three other liars!

Star Inkbright said...

@Snow: *checks my lists* No.

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

Snow investigated Elleni and got unsuspicious

Ace Pennman said...

okay, thanks

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

You're the only one, snow.

I've made myself a little table.

Star Inkbright said...

Jai - u - Lav
Gemma - s - Lav
Keiron - u - Lav
Lua - s - Lav
Dugglyn - u - Star
Snow - u - Jai
Elleni - u - Lua
Lav - s - Gemma
Star - u - Snow

Lav - s - Star
Dugglyn - u - Gemma
Snow - u - Elleni
Jai - u - Lua
Gemma - s - Lav
Star - u - Keiron

Star Inkbright said...

@Gemma: Table sounds like a good idea . . .

Ace Pennman said...

do we think we're going to hang someone today? personally, I feel like we need more info but *shrugs*

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

No i don't think we have enough. I think everyone should have like one more night to say who to investigate and see if someone else dies. Then we discuss who we should hang. But i still think it's going to be too early. I don't want a repeat happening like in the last game where someone innocent dies.

Harry, Richard, Hak, Conductor (keiron) said...

( -keiron has emailed fabi as his results didn't come in yet- or maybe it was him who shot lua :P nah kidding I investigated star but not got a result yet :P

and star I'm on to you, :P you said your not mafia but you didn't say you are a cop *slithers away * )

Star Inkbright said...

@Keiron: I'm a cop


:)

Abd dude if I'm the doctor or whoever the result will still come back unsuspicious if you'Re the regular cop

Star Inkbright said...

And, yeah . . . I don't feel like I have enough info yet. I don't want to vote to hang someone till I think they're a Mafioso, abd I don't think that yet.
We only have a limited amount of time, but we have an extra night coz no one died the first night, so . . .

Harry, Richard, Hak, Conductor (keiron) said...

but if it suspicious and I have reason to believe it will then I know I'm insane which means lav is mafia :P )

Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...

I definitely don't think we should hang anyone until we know more. Last time that happened evil duggy won by drowning El I'm retrified beans after hanging Gemma, shooting me and stabbing Snow. Twice. So yeah, I think we should wait until we have more info this time.

Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...

**in

Lavender Hope said...

Hey Star? You put down Gemma - s - Lav twice. Just pointing that out.

Also, I agree that we should wait another night. But are we going to plan who we're investigating next?
*hasn't made a table*

*probably should*
Although I'm planning this out all on here, so if I need evidence, I could just look through the comments.

Lavender Hope said...

@Keiron: /or/ I could be the doctor, coroner, or survivor?

Who knows? I could have been the attempted victim on the first night.

Lavender Hope said...

Or saved the attempted victim.
*nods*

Lavender Hope said...

Unless /you're/ lying and is the one trying to set me up?
*gives Keiron a side glance*

Harry, Richard, Hak, Conductor (keiron) said...

( if I'm insane you can't be thou :P )

Lavender Hope said...

Oh wait, that didn't even make sense...
*facepalms*
But you get what I meant.

Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...

Right. We should organize ourselves.
First - Who do we think the Mafia will try kill next?
Second - Who should we all investigate?
We could split into groups of three? Then investigate a certain person each in our groups?

Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...

There are 8 people left, so maybe two groups of four?

Lavender Hope said...

You could still be lying, trying to set me up. Just saying.

How can you be trusted?? *eyeballs him*

*wishes there was an actual face she could make instead of using the action*
Would be lots more understandable I think.

Lavender Hope said...

*nods to Jai*
That sounds like a good idea.

Lavender Hope said...

How are we going to split?


Also, we still need some people's results. We should probably wait for them before taking any other actions.

Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...

How aboutttttt

Me, Dug, Star and Snow investigate Lav?

Then Gem, Keiron, Lav and El investigate someone else?

Lavender Hope said...

Also, they might have results that could clear up a bit of confusion.

Harry, Richard, Hak, Conductor (keiron) said...

(*doesn't want to split or give people ideas feels like that will get him killed*)

Lavender Hope said...

Before deciding on anything, let's wait for everyone else's opinion.

Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...

Idk. It's up to everyone else obviously, in all fairness it didn't really go well last time so I can understand why others wouldn't want to.
Maybe wait for the others to comment their results.

Lavender Hope said...

*nods in agreement*

Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...

Okay then

Lavender Hope said...

Uh... Jai, also I found something wrong with that idea.

You already investigated me, remember?

So someone else will have to.

Lavender Hope said...

El is the only other one not in that group who didn't investigate me yet.

Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...

El and me could swap? I don't think she investigated you yet? Unless she did last night.

Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...

Okay, swap me and El then.

Lavender Hope said...

Also, who should I investigate next?

I've been investigating people at random. It would be nice to have a plan.

Lavender Hope said...

*nods to Jai*

Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...

Well who is currently being considered the main suspects?

Lavender Hope said...

Uh... Me?

But since I can't investigate myself(not to mention I already somewhat know my role), I'll need someone else who seems suspicious. But the problem is, the Mafiosi are really good at hiding themselves...

Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...

We could decide the second person after everyone else has contributed, see who else is suspicious.

Lavender Hope said...

*thinks more*
Lua was a cop and the only one who died.

Which means that the coroner could look up her last investigation... Could the Mafiosi somehow have had a hunch of who she investigated and killed her before she could share it?

They'd have to be really good at predictions if that's true...

Lavender Hope said...

*nods*

Lavender Hope said...

*this game is giving me a distraction from thinking about cats*
*is thankful because otherwise I'd be crying right now*
*but that is irrelevant to the conversations*
*in other words, please ignore*
*thank you*

Star Inkbright said...

Dunno. I don't think it's likely it was a motivated killing.

Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...

We can't really know until we've more data.



Also Lav have you read the story link from the forest of thingy blog/your email?

Star Inkbright said...

But yeah, I'll investigate Lav. :)

Lavender Hope said...

@Jai: yeah; I left a reply, but I'll just say that it's great and there are just a few missing punctuation marks and grammatical errors that I'll point out when I have more time. :)

Harry, Richard, Hak, Conductor (keiron) said...

( Ok so STar= unsuspicious :( )

Lavender Hope said...

That could mean you're the naive cop? Or possibly normal?

Lavender Hope said...

Or lying, but anyone could be lying, so just if you were a cop.

Lavender Hope said...

Wait though, you could still be insane.

Hmm... Well this doesn't tell us much.

Star Inkbright said...

Yes! *fistpump*
I told you I wasn't suspicious!!

Yeah, Keiron is regular, naive, insane and investigated both the Mafia members, or lying.

Star Inkbright said...

I think it's only Elleni we have to hear back from now.

Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...

Hmm

Star Inkbright said...

*sigh* I suck st strategy games
Good at looking at information, not good at drawing conclusions from it
*stares at lists, wishing them to reveal their secrets to me*
*waits for Elleni*

Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...

Sorry, for some reason my phone decided to post hmm again.

Vellichor said...

I investigated Jai and I got unsuspicious
Since I got unsuspicious for Lua, I'm naive or regular

Also, it's possible that both Gemma and Lavender were telling the truth, even if Lua was a cop, because they could all be regular, insane, and paranoid, and all get 'suspicious' for someone.

We shouldn't hang anyone yet. Coroner is going to be super important for tomorrow, whether they find Lua's role or what she investigated, so let's hope they're not killed.

Vellichor said...

Wait, Fabi, if a doctor, coroner, or survivor, dies, do we know? Will it say, for example, "Fabi, Survivor" when you tell the story?

Hamlet, Prince of Denmark | Moss Elsinore Cryptic | Fabi S. said...

Yeah. All the cops just say Cop instead of what kind, but the other roles will be more specific.

[hums Survivor by Destiny's Child]

Star Inkbright said...

@Elleni: No, because if Lua is regular, she got suspicious fir Lav so Lav is mafia
If Lav is regular, she got suspicious fir Gemma so Gemma is Mafia
If Gemma is regular, she got suspicious fir Lav so Lav is Mafia

You get me? They can't all be cops. Not possible.

Star Inkbright said...

(Although of course Gemma isn't regular coz she got suspicious for Lua)

Vellichor said...

...
OH
I DIDN'T EVEN THINK OF THAT
omg
wow
ok
so Coroner should first investigate what role Lua is then

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

Welp goodnight, i'm going to bed.

Hamlet, Prince of Denmark | Moss Elsinore Cryptic | Fabi S. said...

You have a little less than 12 hours to select a suspect.

I've spent a little less than 10 hours at the theater, and I was dancing for most of it.

My feet hurt.

Dugglyn Carzainia said...

OMLI Fabi!

Our dance class is only and hour and a half and it's not enough :/

But last class I was trying on some new shoes for feises and I wrapped up my toes that normally get blisters because my goodness, they're small! But I can go high on my toes really easily and my point looks so good 😍
But I didn't wrap up my big toe and now I have a raw patch of skin and two blisters on one toe >.<


Almost 10 hours though. Wow.

Hamlet, Prince of Denmark | Moss Elsinore Cryptic | Fabi S. said...

This was tech week, so we had to go through each piece several times and figure out the lighting and stuff, so it was meant to take a while.

However, I probably shouldn't be discussing that here.

I hope your blisters feel better soon though.

Hamlet, Prince of Denmark | Moss Elsinore Cryptic | Fabi S. said...

But yeah, that's why I didn't have the day end tonight.

Vellichor said...

Wait what's the game plan for tonight again?

Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...

@El we're still deciding. We didn't want to make a decision without your results.

Harry, Richard, Hak, Conductor (keiron) said...

( I think we should vote to skip day )

Lavender Hope said...

*nods in agreement*

Star Inkbright said...

I don't feel I have enough info to vote for anyone, so . . . okay. :)

Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...

But we haven't a plan? That'd just help the Mafia.

Star Inkbright said...

Comment 101!

(Sorry it was my old house number)

Star Inkbright said...

Oh hell naw!

*glares at Jai, then smiles to show I'm not seriously mad*

Um
*looks helpless*
*doesn't know what to plan*

Star Inkbright said...

You're right though. A plan would probably be profitable.

Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...

Sorry star xD


Not to mention fabi is probably asleep (she better be) and so won't start night till she's woken up.

Star Inkbright said...

@Jai: *nods* True.

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

Welp i think that splitting into teams is a good thing. I think we should investigate some of the liars. So i'm going to ask everyone again to say who they are most suspicious of and we'll do a vote for the top 2 people then split into teams of 4? or 2? but teams of 2 will mean that we might put the two mafia in a team. And a team of 4 will take longer to investigate everyone. So whatever you guys think but i like that plan.

I'll put a tally of the number of times each person has been investigated to help decide.

Lavender ||||
Gemma ||
Star |||
Snow |
Keiron |
Sil |

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

Omg Keiron i just thought of a great plan. Instead of investigating me because you believe i'm a cop and that'll tell you what you are, you can investigate Lua because we know she was a cop, even if she's dead. Right?

Star Inkbright said...

Woah I've been investigated a lot of times
*kind of honoured* :)

Omg Gemma that's such a good idea!!!!!!!!!!!!

Yeah, if people investigate Lua, it'll help them work out what they are. Which is a really good idea. However . . . if people do that, it won't help us find out info about anyone suspicious, so . . .
*ponders with a frown*

Harry, Richard, Hak, Conductor (keiron) said...

( I can't investigate a dead person can I ? )

Harry, Richard, Hak, Conductor (keiron) said...

( who investigated me? *don't think I seen that* )

Star Inkbright said...

@Keiron: Me.
Unsuspicious. :)

I don't know if you can investigate dead people or not . . . I assume you can. *frowns* Might be best to check though.

Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...

Gemma I've been investigated twice, by El and Snow.

Harry, Richard, Hak, Conductor (keiron) said...

(woohoo :D )

Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...

I don't think you can investigate dead people. The coroner can look at their position or last investigation but other than that..

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

That is true Star, so there is a risk to it but at least people would be able to tell who they are because most people are down to 2 options. And 3 cops left to find. And then we can start hanging people because we can be certain of who is mafia. Although i'm really hoping Lua wasn't regular. The coroner would be able to tell us that. But they don't want to show themselves which kinda sucks.

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

Oh yeah jai sorry, i hadn't put in Elleni's results yet for the 2nd night. That's 2 investigations for sil too.

But we really need to ask fabi if we can investigate a dead person. That's how we split into teams? half investigate Lua and find out what they are and half investigate the most suspicious person that we vote?

Star Inkbright said...

Yeah . . . :/ The coroner's investigation won't do us much good if we don't know about it.

@Gemma: *nods* :) Sounds like a good idea. If we're allowed to investigate Lua.

Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...

Well who is everyone suspicious of?

Star Inkbright said...

@Jai: Idk.
I'm suspicious of everyone who isn't Lua or myself. :P

Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...

Yes but is there anyone you're more suspicious of than others?

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

Well for me it really could be anyone
Star
Snow
Duggy
Elleni
Sil

I've always been kinda thinking it's lavender, and obviously other people think that too. But i also think that maybe she wouldn't have because it did look as if someone set her up.

And i really don't think it's keiron. I think Keiron is insane, i'm paranoid and Lua was regular. Now we just need to find the last cop, Naive. Although the naive cop won't help much with finding out who it is.

Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...

I'm probably most suspicious of Lav and Keiron, but honestly I don't know. Lav could be getting set up and there's no evidence against Keiron, that's just a gut feeling.

Star Inkbright said...

I really don't think Keiron is insane purely because I don't think I'm a Mafioso. :P

I think there is a chance it could be Lavender, but I don't think the chance is high enough for me to think it's her. Either Lav or you, Gemma, is lying, but I don't know which one it is, the other one is definitely a cop, and even though one of you is lying, that doesn't make you the Mafia . . .
So yeah. Idk.
I'd rather either investigate you or Lav though, just because it's less liekly reaching out into the dark. There's so many liars in the group of people pretending to be naive/regular that it's quite daunting to try and even work out who is who. :P

Star Inkbright said...

I have a gut feeling about Lav, have to admit. I'm not suspicious of Keiron though.

Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...

If we can't investigate Lua we could all investigate one person and hope the Mafia would be kind enough to kill them so we all know who they were and thus who we are, but somehow I feel the Mafia wouldn't comply.

Star Inkbright said...

@Jai: *nods*

It would be so much more convenient if we could all discuss without the Mafia listening in . . .

Ace Pennman said...

If you're all looking for someone to investigate, I'll volunteer. I know I'm not guilty and it'll give me an idea of who you guys are...

the only issue is you'd have to trust me, so maybe we pick someone we all trust to tell the truth and investigate them?

idk.

Ace Pennman said...

...

I don't think that last comment made much sense

...

I'm tired...

um

sorry

Star Inkbright said...

@Snow: :) No, it made sense to me. *hugs*

Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...

It made sense to me snow :) It's just a case of do we trust you.

Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...

And no offense but I don't think anykme fully trust anyone at the moment.

Star Inkbright said...

*nods at Jai* same.

Dugglyn Carzainia said...

We got to remember there's two mafia members.

So if one cop found (random example) Gemma suspicious and Star suspicious and we decide thAt cop was regular, we can't forget about the other person the investigated.

Star Inkbright said...

@Dugglyn: I know. But because we don't know who's regular and who's not . . . *shrugs*

Dugglyn Carzainia said...

**they


Does that make sense?

Dugglyn Carzainia said...

@Star Yep, just as we start to (hopefully) figure it out that will need to be remembered.

Hamlet, Prince of Denmark | Moss Elsinore Cryptic | Fabi S. said...

You can investigate dead people if you're the coroner. That's what that role is for.
If you're not the coroner, sorry but nope.

Lavender Hope said...

Yeah, with me being half and half, I'm totally the suspicious one. :P

But I guess, I investigated Star and Gemma, so... Tonight I could investigate Jai? If that's okay? No real reason, I just choose random people to investigate.

Star Inkbright said...

@Dugglyn: That's why I have a list. :)

I could probably format my list better, though. *thoughtful*

@Lantern: *nods* Thanks. :)

Damn that's annoying, but it makes sense.