Thursday, April 28, 2016

Round 2 Day 2

When the sun rose over the town, there was no dead body to be seen. Whispers echoed around the square. What did this mean? Were the powers that be simply feeling merciful, or was something deeper going on?

You'll all receive emails with your night action results, even if you decided to do nothing.

Comment moderation will be turned off as soon as I've emailed out the results of everyone's night actions. You can use this time to discuss amongst yourselves in the comment section and try to sleuth out the mafioso. You do not have to share the results of your investigations, though failing to do so may make you seem suspicious.

If you want to hang a suspected mafioso, you can type castvote [player's name]
If you type "vote" rather than "castvote," your vote will be valid if I see it. However, I'm gonna Ctrl-F "castvote" when tallying up, so that's not a guarantee. Also please avoid using the word castvote when you're not voting.
If you want to redact a vote (which you can only do before it's reached a majority), type unvote. Please use bold! The code for that is <b>Bold text</b>

You are not obligated to hang somebody, though failing to do so may give the mafioso an advantage. However, hanging an innocent citizen has very major bad consequences in a game this small.

The day will end Friday April 29th, at 9PM Pacific Time (5AM UK time on Saturday) unless a majority is reached and a suspect is selected, or unless people vote skip day, which also requires a majority vote.

If a suspect is selected, their 24-hour defense phase will begin immediately, even if I am not online to say so. During that time, you may castvote innocent or guilty, and you may change your vote at any time. The vote will not lock until the end of the defense phase.


The majority of votes needed today is 5.

If you have any questions, comment them in italics or email me.

Round 2 Players
1) Gemma
2) Dugglyn
3) Star
4) Lavender
5) Silente (Jai)
6) Lua
7) Vellichor (Elleni)
8) Keiron
9) Snow

Roles

1) Mafioso
2) Mafioso

3) Cop
4) Cop
5) Cop
6) Cop

7) Doctor
8) Coroner

9) Survivor

Player order and role order not related. Role assignments generated randomly.

169 comments:

Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...

Wait, no one died?

Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...

That's brilliant!!!

Ace Pennman said...

looks that way

Ace Pennman said...

I'm guessing the mafioso either couldn't come to an agreement or weren't both around... (or they think they're being sneaky :P)

Hamlet, Prince of Denmark | Moss Elsinore Cryptic | Fabi S. said...

Confirmed: No one died. There are several reasons why that might be the case. Only some of you will know which reason is the one that actually happened.

Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...

Hopefully it's that they both forgot or couldn't agree, but it could be the doctor or the survivor that gained us an extra day?

Star Inkbright said...

I guesstimate that this is down to the survivor.
Wait
But we have two mafiosos
Hmmm
Maybe one didn't kill anyone and the other tried to but they taken ed the survivor who was wearing their vest . . . ?

Dude. This is mysterious. O_O

Star Inkbright said...

Right. I ran off to te-read the rules. Only one killing per night maximum. Meaning this is either tactical (maybe they want to suss us out before deciding who to kill? Idk) or once again, survivor. I think it's more likely to be the survivor than the doctor, personally. However I guess the doctor is a possibility.

Essentially I don't know. XD

Star Inkbright said...

^re-read

Star Inkbright said...

If it is tactical this rather makes me suspect Elleni. She seems very tactical. XD

Hamlet, Prince of Denmark | Moss Elsinore Cryptic | Fabi S. said...

Admin powers incoming!

Deleted and removed Star's duplicated comments because I can actually do that. Cool.

Admin powers outgoing!

PS--I should stop saying that...

Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...

But the night ended early, that must mean that everyone submitted an action doesn't it?

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

I investigated Lav and got suspicious
So either paranoid, regular or insane.

Star Inkbright said...

@Lantern: Thanks. :) Sorry. Idk what happened there. :/

@Jai: They could submit the action "do nothinG."

On second thoughts, I don't think it's at all profitable to not kill anyone, though. It gives people one more day to get onto you and means it takes you longer to complete your objective.
So yeahhhh I think it'll be the survivor or the doctor. Probably the survivor - seems more likely.

Sorry if this comment duplicates too.

Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...

I investigated Lav and got unspicious, so I'm either niave, regular or insane.

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

I won't be on much because everything I said last game lead to me being hung.

But I have something to ask. How does the doctor heal people? do they have to say the name of who to heal or to they just be like "heal the person that got stabbed tonight" or something?

Hamlet, Prince of Denmark | Moss Elsinore Cryptic | Fabi S. said...

They have to say who they heal without knowing who will be attacked. If they could just say "heal whoever the Mafia kill", it'd be a very OP role.

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

Right ok, was wondering. It would be really difficult if they had to guess who to kill. If there a limitation on how many people the doctor can heal on the game? you said the survivor has 2 vests, if they used one last night they're down to one but I don't really think it was and if it was the surviver that stopped the attack last night, the mafia knows who it is so in another 2 rounds they'll be dead. Unless the doctor heals them

Hamlet, Prince of Denmark | Moss Elsinore Cryptic | Fabi S. said...

No limits to how many people the doctor can heal. As long as they keep guessing who the mafia's going to kill, they can heal people as often as they want.

They are limited to only one self-heal though.

And the survivor isn't necessarily doomed if the Mafia figures out who they are. The survivor isn't on either side. The Mafia's goal is to kill everyone on the town side, and since the survivor isn't on the town side, the Mafia don't have to kill them to win. However, they could quite possibly do so anyway, depending on how the survivor sides voting-wise, and depending on whether or not they believe someone who says they're the survivor is actually a more powerful town role trying to hide.

Dugglyn Carzainia said...

Unless of course the Mafia moves onto a different person to kill.

*is surprised no one died*


Do the Mafia members know if it was the doctor or the survivor?

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

Hmm, interesting.

How does the doctor know when to use self-heal? would they just have to guess a night to use it and if they get it wrong they die?

So many questions I need clearing up but it's so interesting to know more about the game.

Star Inkbright said...

@Gemma: Not necessarily. If I were the Mafia and I'd tried to kill the Survivor last night, I'd go after someone else tonight. Firstly bevause anyone else is an easier target - why spend two nights killing one Survivor when you can spend two nights killing two cops? - and secondly because the Survivor can't investigate me or find out anything about me or heal anyone. The Survivor is actually the player that provides the least amount of threat to me.

So yeah, I'd like to be the Survivor right now. :P

I investigated Snow and got unsuspicious. So . . . I'm not paranoid, apparently. Yay?

Star Inkbright said...

Oh . . . when you said the Mafia had to kill EVERYONE to win, I assumed that meant the Survivor toO.

Either way - I'd love to be the Survivor right now. XD

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

You're Niave Regular or insane, Star.

Star Inkbright said...

@Gemma: Apparently. :)

Hamlet, Prince of Denmark | Moss Elsinore Cryptic | Fabi S. said...

@Dugglyn They might know, but if they do it's not because I told them. "Your target was healed" or "You killed someone who was immune"

@Gemma They don't know. If they don't self-heal on night 43 and the Mafia decides to kill them on night 43 (not that there will be a 43), they die. The role is meant more to emphasize healing others, they just have one self-heal in case they feel they need it.

And you can ask as many questions if you need to.

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

Keiron's internet is fucking up which is preventing him from commenting. So he said that he investigated Lavender and got unsuspicious. So already, either Keiron, Jaimie or you Star, are lying. As there can't be 3 possibly Naive cops. Unless Fabi has added more than one of one kind of cop.

I'm the only possibly paranoid cop so far so there has to be someone else who is a cop and got suspicious for someone.

Also of course the doctor will have to lie as they don't want the mafia finding out who they are. And the mafia will have to lie. The survivor and coroner can choose to lie if they want. So we have 5 possible liars.

Hamlet, Prince of Denmark | Moss Elsinore Cryptic | Fabi S. said...

@Star That may be a leftover from the previous game. Where does it say that?

Anyway, the Mafia has to kill the entire town. The survivor is neutral and doesn't fall into that category.

Hamlet, Prince of Denmark | Moss Elsinore Cryptic | Fabi S. said...

There's only one of each kind of cop.

However, basically every non-cop has the motivation to pretend to be a cop.

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

Yup.

Dugglyn Carzainia said...

Oh yeah, I investigated Star and got Unsuspicious

Dugglyn Carzainia said...

*frowns at so many people getting Unsuspicious *
Which one of you is lying?

Star Inkbright said...

"Mafioso: Can kill one person each night. Goal is to avoid detection and kill everyone else."

@Gemma: There's nine players and nine roles.

But nah, you, Keiron and Jai could still be all telling the truth. She could be innocent, Keiron could be naive, Jai could be regular, abd you could be insane/paranoid. Or she could be guilty, Jai is naive, you're regular and Keiron is insane. Etc.
*doesn't THINK anyone else has posted investigation results . . .*

Star Inkbright said...

Oh gosh thus is getting confusing . . .

Right five people are saying they're cops. A minimum of one of us is lying.

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

Ikr Dug? So many. Even after i just said that there was so many. Which makes me believe that it's not you, but you fooled everyone (apart from partly me because i did strongly suspect you one day) last round so i'm keeping my eyes on you.

Love how i said i wouldn't be commenting much as the way i spoke apparently gave stuff away last game and i got hung when i was innocent lol.

Hamlet, Prince of Denmark | Moss Elsinore Cryptic | Fabi S. said...

Yup, that was copy-pasted from the last game. If Mafiosi wanted to kill everyone else, that would include each other. Fixed.

Star Inkbright said...

I think Dugglyn's the Survivor. She said she was surprised, but she didn't sound all that surprised. And I think if she were a Mafioso she'd be trying harder to pretend. Plus there are too many cops being unsuspicious.
Plus idk I just feel like she's lying.

*frowns at Dugglyn* No offence.

This swarm of unsuspiciousness makes it less likely that Gemma is lying, because she's the only one having got suspicion.
So far. :P

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

Well if all but that person, that extra one, is telling the truth that means i'm paranoid as i'm the only one that got suspicious. And that sucks because i'm basically useless because i suspect everyone.

Star Inkbright said...

@Lantern: :) Thanks.

Star Inkbright said...

@Gemma: If you are paranoid, it's still useful because you help us identify the other cops.
And idk. You could still be regular or insane. If EVERYONE is pretending to be a cop, then two or three of us could be lying and the suspicious cop could be one of the others.

Star Inkbright said...

^paranoid

Not suspicious

Star Inkbright said...

^the cops could also be lying about their results, but they don't really have a motive to do that.

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

The later you comment the more difficult it is to lie really.

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

Which is why i'm kinda surprised Duggy still said she got unsuspicious. A liar would have noticed that there were too many people saying they got unsuspicious and went for suspicious like me but maybe for a different person? Which is why i don't think it's duggy but again, she lied and fooled everyone last game so idk anymore.

Star Inkbright said...

@Gemma: In a way, yeah . . .

Star Inkbright said...

@Gemma: Well maybe it was a double bluff and Dugglyn said "unsuspicious" because she thought "well they wouldn't think a liar would say "unsuspicious" this late" . . .

I think it's impossible to really know.

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

Yeah it's basically impossible to tell anything the first night.

Star Inkbright said...

Particularly as no one has died. :( If someone had died we'd only have eight roles to suss out . . .

Dugglyn Carzainia said...

Idk whether or not Lua is a Mafia but just know she's currently asleep which is why she can't comment.

Dugglyn Carzainia said...

But ugh it's so much harder not being the Mafia

Dugglyn Carzainia said...

Though being the Mafia was more stressful

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

There is plenty of time for the others to comment. another 6 hours or so.

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

Though we should possibly talk about who we're investigating tonight. I suggest one of the liars but i'm not sure who so everyone should possibly say who they're most suspicious of so far and we split up people to investigate them in teams possibly? depending on how many different people are said.

I'm thinking Duggy or Star.
I may just be being Naive but i don't think it's Keiron because he said who was going to investigate and what conclusion he got right after me but couldn't comment. Or see Jai's comment. Or star's.

Hamlet, Prince of Denmark | Moss Elsinore Cryptic | Fabi S. said...

One day and six hours, actually. I forgot to add in the time conversion that it's actually Saturday at 5:00 in the UK, even though it's still Friday my time.

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

And Jai commented 2nd although maybe that's just because she saw i investigated lav for paranoid and she said the opposite to be safe but idk.

No offense to either duggy or star, I'm less convinced it's duggy because 1: she commented the same although i'm also suspicious for the same reason and because she was mafia last time, i don't think fabi would pick the same person twice in a row but she might, just to screw with us.

I don't have any particular reason to believe it's star tbh. I only have feelings that its not the others?

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

Oh ok Fabi that's plenty of time.

Dugglyn Carzainia said...

I'm not the Mafia this time

There's not really much proof of anything but it's not me

Hamlet, Prince of Denmark | Moss Elsinore Cryptic | Fabi S. said...

@Gemma The roles are determined randomly, so everyone has a 2 in 9 chance of being a baddie.

Harry, Richard, Hak, Conductor (keiron) said...

( I am back omg that was horrible my laptop just about burst into smoke with what just happened :P I have over 10000 processes running in the background and I'm trying to stop them as it's malware )

Lavender Hope said...

*no one died*
*blinks*
Wow, okay. So recap, this could mean the Mafiosi couldn't come to a decision, chose the survivor, the doctor healed the person, or the killers chose /not/ to kill anyone... This is scaryyyyy. >.<

Also, I investigated Gemma and got suspicious, so either I'm paranoid, insane, or regular?

It's also really interesting how Gemma and I investigated each other and are both the only suspicious ones so far...

Hmm... Unless one of us is lying? Or both of us? Though it makes more sense that someone who's gotten unsuspicious is a liar.

This is confusing. And I'm probably reading too much into everything. >.<

Lavender Hope said...

*also kinda sucks that I'm late to the party due to time zones*
*but that's not anyone's fault, nor should anyone feel the need to change the times of the game phases*

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

That is interesting, lavender.

Lavender Hope said...

*nods*
*doesn't know what else to say*
Do /you/ have any ideas or...?

*is also going to add that she's distant so apologies for late replies*

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

Well i know you're not regular so if you're telling the truth you're paranoid or insane. And being Naive or paranoid sucks.

Keiron and I are plotting on a skype call but i still don't know if he's lying so i'm hoping for the best.

Dugglyn Carzainia said...

Gemma, you can't plot with Keiron!

You're not supposed to talk about it anywhere outside of this blog.
(Unless you're the Mafia)

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

Ok do you want us to write down our whole plan then?

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

Is that counted as cheating because we didn't write it down here first even though i don't know if he's lying to me or not and vice versa?

Harry, Richard, Hak, Conductor (keiron) said...

( I am doing the plan either way, I can't trust her just coz we're on skype :P :3

we've both said we're cops if we choose to believe each other then there is already a way to see who the mafia is .)

Dugglyn Carzainia said...

Additionally, the first rule of Mafia is that we don't talk about Mafia outside of the Mafia blog! Things like "hey dude, check my most recent post in Mafia" are okay, and you can always email Fabi the admin about the game, but anything else will be considered cheating. Absolutely no emailing people your roles or discussing strategy outside of the game. There's only one mafioso, so there won't be a night chat this game.

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

I'm kinda scared now that Fabi will give us into trouble and say it was cheating ;-; i really hope it's not.

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

Oh shit.

Harry, Richard, Hak, Conductor (keiron) said...

( the only way I'm going to be able to tell i shes lying is if she shows me her email it's the same as talking on here. )

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

:S do you think we'll have to restart or something now?

Basically we were going to investigate each other. If i get unsuspicious either lav or keiron is the mafia, or both. If i get suspicious i'm paranoid or insane. if keiron gets suspicious for me he's insane and i'm paranoid and lav is the mafia.

Lavender Hope said...

Yeah, and I really hope I'm not paranoid...

About the whole plotting with Keiron thing, at least you know now, so please try to keep the cop plotting to your individual selves until the day phases, please?

Dugglyn Carzainia said...

So it's the fact your are discussing outside the blog is why it's cheating.

Even though I frequently text with Lua, the only thing I've said about this game to her is explaining how to comment night actions


"Nope just put down a name and Fabi knows who is who.
Or you just say "investigate person" or "kill person" or something like that"

Dugglyn Carzainia said...

Idk

I hope not and I doubt it but just know for next time!

Lavender Hope said...

Maybe change the plan. Investigate other people and then maybe each other but during different night phases?

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

It was just really hard to not talk about it because we talk like every moment or every day but i won't anymore if that makes any difference...i really hope we didnt ruin it for you guys.

Lavender Hope said...

Also, we should think about everyone else. If one of you /is/ lying, then you could be the doctor, survivor, or even the one who investigates dead people!(this is minus the mafia and I forgot the spelling of the last option)

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

Why would that change anything, Lav? if the game is still going on then i'm continuing with the plan i was going for.

But i'm betting Fabi will give us into trouble and we'll have to restart or something :-/

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

Coroner. I think?

Harry, Richard, Hak, Conductor (keiron) said...

( exactly lav I could be telling her that shes suspiscious so she believes it's you when really I'm the doctor or something, theres no way to tell )

Lavender Hope said...

It's fine, Gemma. As I said, maybe the best way to keep enjoying the current game is to change what you planned. Or one of you could stick with it and the other investigate someone else.

Just, if you're going to chat on skype, you can /talk/ about it, but don't voice suspicions. Just an idea.

Dugglyn Carzainia said...

I understand, because I frequently talk about it to my school friend because they're not playing and they put up with my ranting and scheming XD

Lavender Hope said...

At least you've got people not playing the game to soundboard off of, Duggy. :P

Lavender Hope said...

@Gemma about spelling: Thanks. ^.^ Knew it was something like that, but I think I tried spelling it cronor. :P

Harry, Richard, Hak, Conductor (keiron) said...

( PLus the reason we talked about it was coz my int was dying so I told her to say who AND what I got. :P then we laughed saying she chose you too . )

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

Yeah...The only person that i have to talk to really is Keiron and that made me spout everything but it won't happen again if the game continues...still don't think fabi will let it.

If it does one of us will change, probably me.

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

Yep that's how it happened, blame Keiron. It's all his fault.

Lavender Hope said...

I don't think Moss would do that unless you guys continue plotting together(UNLESS YOU'RE BOTH MAFIOSOS AND ARE TRYING TO CONFUSE US!!! :OOOOO)

But if you're not, and you'll stop plotting, we should be okay.

Lavender Hope said...

Also, SORRY FOR CAPS! I just had that thought and was really surprised about the idea...

Harry, Richard, Hak, Conductor (keiron) said...

(* yup pulls out dunkin doughnut * *knife he means knife* )

Lavender Hope said...

However... I think this just put a lot more tension into the game. Liars, schemers, cops, mafia, and everyone else in the town. :0

Lavender Hope said...

*leans away from possible killer*
O.O

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

Sorry Fabi if we ruined the game. But i'll hope you give us and everyone else playing a chance to continue it cause lav and duggy don't seem to mind that we epicly fucked up?

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

Keiron is asleep and i'll be going to sleep the now so Goodnight and i hope Fabi forgives us enough to keep it going as long as everyone agrees to keep us in. If they don't they'll need to start a new game. And i probably won't play if i ruin this one :-/

Lavender Hope said...

*hugs Gemma*
I think it's fine. :) If anything, it adds another layer to confuse people. Could you both be from the Mafia and are trying to fix it by coming up with this story? Or, if you're being truthful, either of you could still be lying about who's who and as long as you don't do it again, there's still enough mystery and confusion to make it interesting for the rest of us.

That's okay, right, Moss?

Also, I hope you two sleep well. And try not to worry too much. :)

Lavender Hope said...

I gotta go now, too.


OH AND WE STILL NEED TO FIGURE OUT WHO TO HANG.

Let's not forget that's the reason for the day phase.

Vellichor said...

Hooooooly moly
Sorry guys, I forgot Mafia was happening lol

Umm
Yeah
So

Star -> Snow = unsuspicious
Keiron -> Lav = unsuspicious
Dugg -> Star = unsuspicious
Jai -> Lav = unsuspicious

And finally

Vellichor -> Lua = unsuspicious


How
This is seriously hurting my brain

Vellichor said...

Three of us are lying

Dugglyn Carzainia said...

>.<

So many Unsuspicious

Dugglyn Carzainia said...

But El, you forgot 2 people also got suspicious for someone.

And here can only be 4 cops

Vellichor said...

I know
I only counted the people who got unsuspicious for now

Ace Pennman said...

Don't really have time to read through all the comments (school) but I investigate Sil and got unsuspicious. So yeah

Dugglyn Carzainia said...

XD

more Unsuspicious people

Vellichor said...

WTF

Vellichor said...

HOW

Hamlet, Prince of Denmark | Moss Elsinore Cryptic | Fabi S. said...

Um. Taking a message for someone w/ no internet access is ok. If it wasn't, I'd have said something before. Discussing strategy is not.

Asking someone about the rules or what a role does (as long as you don't imply that the role is your own) is ok.

Making coordinated plans outside of the public thread or telling anyone your role is not. Yes you could just as easily be lying.

I'm not going to start the game over, but I'm gonna give out a warning, and I may do something else when I read back, if I decide it's warranted.

There's a certain amount of outside talking that's going to happen, but yeah. Um.

I'll deal with this when I get home from dance.

Hamlet, Prince of Denmark | Moss Elsinore Cryptic | Fabi S. said...

Posting again before dinner break is over, but I still haven't read back, nor seen any posts since my last comment.

The thing is, it gives you no advantage. People can lie just as easily outside of the game as inside the game, so it can't give you an advantage unless you literally forward each other your role emails (please tell me you didn't do that). And it makes it a lot harder on the host, and it can be unfair to other players, and yeah.

Vellichor said...

WHY

Dugglyn Carzainia said...

IDKKKKKKKK

Ace Pennman said...

I'm guessing there ae lots of "unsuspicious" people than?

We do have more members... but maybe the Doc and Coroner are trying to hide as well? It'd make sense. If the Mafia knew them, they'd be quickly killed (at least, that's what I'd do :P)

Ace Pennman said...

So we'd have 4 (possibly 5) people pretending to be cops and 4 actual cops

Hamlet, Prince of Denmark | Moss Elsinore Cryptic | Fabi S. said...


Ok. I'm not restarting, nor am I kicking anyone out of the game.

It doesn't sound like you actually did anything hugely hugely wrong, but I hope you understand that it's frustrating to me. I have no way to tell if you're telling the truth about how much you talked about it, because I can't keep an eye on that.

Literally everyone is claiming to be a cop, so while claiming a role over Skype is not cool, it doesn't affect the game hugely

It also sounds like this happened out of ignorance of the rules rather than intentional cheating. I also am partially responsible, since I didn't post the "first rule of Mafia" in this game. However, Gemma was in the last game, so she really ought to have remembered. Either way, you're both very much aware of the rules now. No discussing strategies outside of the proper places to do so.

I'm also imposing a small penalty, nothing beyond what's fair. If you're telling the truth and are both cops, you won't be able to go through with your plan of investigating each other for the next two nights, though you can investigate anyone else in the game. If either of you is the doctor, you won't be able to heal the other. If either of you is part of the Mafia, you won't be able to kill the other, though you could get your fellow mafioso to do it, unless you are both Mafiosi. (I'll note for everyone's benefit that the Mafiosi only share a day chat, not a night chat) If you're the coroner or survivor, you won't be affected.

If you don't think this is fair, take it up with me over email.

Vellichor said...

I say it's reasonable.

Hamlet, Prince of Denmark | Moss Elsinore Cryptic | Fabi S. said...

I do too.

(Comments disappeared and reappeared because I was re-wording a thing, but I'm gonna add another bold thing so people don't skim past this)

Please read my comment directly above Vellichor's

Dugglyn Carzainia said...

Agreed!

Star Inkbright said...

*wanders in* *reads comments*

OH MY GOSH HOW
WHY IS EVERYONE SO UNSUSPICIOUS XD

Star Inkbright said...

I think it'll kinda be hard to work out who is lying until a bit later in the game, once we have a few less players and a few more investigations . . .

Lavender Hope said...

Uh, Star? Is Blogger giving you double comments or are you accidentally sending it twice? :P

Hamlet, Prince of Denmark | Moss Elsinore Cryptic | Fabi S. said...

Idk but I can remove them because I'm powerful.

Vellichor said...

Lol Fabi XD

Star Inkbright said...

@Lav: I have no idea. O_O
But fortunately Powerful Fabi is here to help me out. :)

Lavender Hope said...

All hail the Powerful Moss. :P

Ace Pennman said...

okay, so... we can't work out who tha mafioso are yet, not really, but...

who do we think is going to be killed next?

tbh if El isn't the Murder, I'd say she will be bc she was best at trying to strategize last game (and this game too, tbh)

...

Hamlet, Prince of Denmark | Moss Elsinore Cryptic | Fabi S. said...

:D

I am powerful!

Ok, I'll stop interrupting the game talk to fuel my ego now.

Star Inkbright said...

@Snow: I agree. I think Elleni's likely to be a target . . .

Hey.
Hey hey.

Mayve Elleni WAS a target last night, but the doctor also thought she'd be a target abd healed her.
That seems likely.

Fabi/Moss/Lantern/Person, if someone was gonna be killed by the Mafia but isn't because the doctor heals them, does the person who was gonna be killed know? I ding THINK this question has been asked before . . . if so, apologies.

Star Inkbright said...

^don't

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

That's completely fine Fabi, Thank you.

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

The only person still to comment is Lua now. Duggy you said that you text her and that she was sleeping last night, could you possibly tell her to come on and comment? even if she doesn't say what her investigation was.

Dugglyn Carzainia said...

Yeah, just a sec!

Hamlet, Prince of Denmark | Moss Elsinore Cryptic | Fabi S. said...

*I made a mistake in my previous long post-y thing. The Mafia only share a night chat, not a day chat. The people who are actually Mafia already know this anyway though.

Hamlet, Prince of Denmark | Moss Elsinore Cryptic | Fabi S. said...

And @Star Yeah, they would know they were attacked and healed, but they wouldn't know the identity of the attacker or doctor.

Dugglyn Carzainia said...

*was wondering about that but doesn't have to worry about it*

Star Inkbright said...

@Lantern: *nods* ah cool.

Hamlet, Prince of Denmark | Moss Elsinore Cryptic | Fabi S. said...

Public Service Announcement: Y'all have 12 hours.

Vellichor said...

Dude I'm not thinking at all this game because it made us lose the last game lmao

Maybe I'll start thinking once someone dies? There are just no clues today.

Lua Evanescence said...

Sorry I haven't commented until now. I investigated Lavender and got 'suspicious'.

Lua Evanescence said...

This doesn't make any sense! Keiron and Jai investigated Lavender too and got unsuspicious... I swear I'm not lying!!

Dugglyn Carzainia said...

Well maybe you're the paranoid cop.

Because there's different kinds of cops that get different answers (see previous posts for info)

Lua Evanescence said...

I must be

Ace Pennman said...

Just letting you guys know (I've already told fabi and worked things out with her) that I'm leaving on a camp in a few hours so I'll probably miss one of the day and night cycles. so if I don't comment, you know why.

Star Inkbright said...

*nods at Snow*

So . . .
Gemma investigated Lav and got suspicious
Keiron investigated Lav and got unsuspicious
Jai investigated Lav and got unsuspicious
Lua investigated Lav and got suspicious . . .

LAV ARE YOU SUSPICIOUS OR NOT XD

Hamlet, Prince of Denmark | Moss Elsinore Cryptic | Fabi S. said...

Don't forget to email me, Snow.

Star Inkbright said...

But so far only Gemma and Lua have got suspicious, I think. So one of them must be paranoid. The other one could be regular but is more likely insane . . .

Vellichor said...

Lavender, Gemma, and Lua claimed they got suspicious
That's three people

Star, Keiron, Dugg, Jai, and I claimed they got unsuspicious
That's five

Literally everyone playing has claimed to be a cop

Vellichor said...

Wait no, one person has not said anything and that's Snow

Ace Pennman said...

I did say something, actually :P

Vellichor said...

Oh
So yes
Literally everyone
Is claiming to be a cop
Wow

Ace Pennman said...

we may have a lot of other rolls trying to pull off the nieve cop roll bc, lets be honest, it'd be the easiest to play without accidentally incriminating someone. Bc The Doc and Coroner wouldn't want to say someone was suspicious and risk getting them killed, so they'd just say everyone was unsuspicious. (If they didn't want to reveal they're roles, which I'm assuming is the case bc of all the cop claiming)

...

games like this would be easier with bigger numbers, so just normal townsfolk can be braught in and not everyone has to claim to be a cop

Star Inkbright said...

*laughs* XD LITERALLY everyone is claiming to be a cop.

@Snow: True.

Star Inkbright said...

Right . . .

So . . .

Lav says she investigated Gemma and got suspicious.
Gemma said she investigated Lav and got suspicious.
One of them is definitely lying.

If Lav is lying, then . . . well that actually doesn't tell us much because she could either be a Mafioso or someone else.
If Gemma is lying, then um . . . well that doesn't tell us much either because Gemma could either be a Mafioso or someone else.

XD John damn it this game is so hard.

Dugglyn Carzainia said...

Actually though, Gemma could be paranoid and Lav could be insane.
So they might actually be lying.

Star Inkbright said...

@Dugglyn: Oh yeah.
Dammit.

Star Inkbright said...

@Dugglyn: If that's the case, then assuming Lua isn't lying she's regular. Which leaves us with one unknown naive cop and a bunch of unsuspicious liars. XD

*is only judging myself from the evidence available to others, as any conclusions based on me being unquestionably honest and innocent won't really be of help to anyone else*
*is using a memo on my phone to complete further deductions based on my knowledge of myself*
*not that I'm getting very far XD*

Star Inkbright said...

Wait no ignore that past comment. Lua got suspicious . . . if neither Gemma nor Lav is lying, then Lua must be lying.

*frowns*

Star Inkbright said...

So . . . at least one out of Gemma, Lav and Lua is lying.

Right well that's sort of ish one liat sussed out. Five more to find . . . XD

Star Inkbright said...

^liar
^four

Harry, Richard, Hak, Conductor (keiron) said...

have I been ruled out lol ? )

Silente Tempest (Jai) - St Of Sinners said...

I don't think anyone has been ruled out yet.
So who are we investigating when night comes?

Amy, Sarah, Aria (Gemma) said...

I think since I have already investigated Lav, and Lua is also claiming to have gotten suspicious for someone, one of them must be lying so i think i'll investigate Lua to see if i get a different result. If not i'm paranoid or insane but i truley think Keiron is insane. We will find out tomorrow.

Lavender Hope said...

Once again, recap:
•Five people are lying. Coroner, doctor, survivor, and the two mafiosos.
•Plus four cops of paranoid, insane, normal, and naive...
•Four people investigated me and I'm currently half and half based on their results. But all of them could be lying because they could be either of the five who aren't cops.
•All but three have investigated people who came up as unsuspicious. But there could only be three real cops with that result.
•The three who got suspicious results could also be the three cops, or they could also be lying.
•There is currently less than two hours left of the day phase.

Conclusion? I vote we skip day and wait till we get more answers.

Lavender Hope said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Lavender Hope said...

Star, Keiron, Dug, Jai, El, and Snow...

Half of these people are lying then.

Lavender Hope said...

Also, adding that either all the ones who got suspicious are cops, or two of them are among the other five and are lying.

But wait...

If that's the case, then /some people/ could be lying about what kind of cop they are??

No, I just confused myself. Ignore that.

I'm just trying to focus on the five who could be lying so it's confusing me a lot.

Lavender Hope said...

Sorry about the deleted comment, it basically repeated what I said underneath it but without the names.

Dugglyn Carzainia said...

So who should I investigate?
Do we have plans like last time or are we just going to free for all again?

Lavender Hope said...

*shrugs*
If you guys start planning, then I'll go with it. But I think most of the UKers are sleeping, so I think it'll be another free for all until the next day phase.

Hi Dug, by the way. :)

This game is so confusing. XP

Hamlet, Prince of Denmark | Moss Elsinore Cryptic | Fabi S. said...

I'm having a really terrible day, so I'm gonna start the night phase early so I can sleep.

Any comments here in the next 15 minutes will be approved, if anyone else has anything to say. However, I'm turning comment moderation on and posting the post.